Home Free Subscription Get Involved Advertise with Us About Us Yellow Pages Team Previous Issue

From Confused to Confident

By Gitika Ahuja

Cocktail Confusion: Being American and Brown


You could say it is part of the excitement. You have no idea what the night will hold. The conversations before the adventure are pretty typical, but where they ultimately lead is wholeheartedly dependent on the night's vibe.

On this particular Friday night we happened upon a smooth hotel bar overflowing with a post-work mob slurping designer drinks. Usually, you know what you're in for—some guy with a loosened tie will make some wannabe sly remark and offer you a cocktail shortly after taking off your coat. You might even accept, even if you have no intentions, but only if he makes it through the offer without spewing saliva all over your freshly bronzed face.

As this particular night began I ordered a glass of champagne, and my fellow Desi gal pal, a dirty martini. Yes, it was as expected, because as sure as Aishwarya Rai's eyes are blue, moments after we slithered to the edge of the snake-shaped cocktail table, a group of blond men nursing their vodka tonics began to stare, almost incessantly, at my friend and me.

One of them tilted over into our immediate space, but oddly didn't say a word. I looked at him and said, "You look like you want to say something." He came up with a bad joke not worth repeating and my bewildered friend and I tried, with all our might, to carry on with our much more compelling conversation.

He persisted and eventually merged his way back: "What's your middle name?" he probed.

"Why would you want to know my middle name, when you don't even know my first?" I rebutted.

That's when the evening got interesting. He looked at both of us one-by-one and asked, "Are you American?"

“Perplexed” didn’t even begin to describe my emotions. I don't even know where the conversation went from there, because my mind was racing. Did he really just ask us if we are American? I must have heard him wrong.

I turned to my friend. She was still speaking to him, but she threw me a look—a look that verified it. He definitely did just ask us if we were American.

I couldn't resist. "Why did you just ask us if we were American?"

Now, it was his turn to be perplexed. Long silence. Twitching eyes. Parched throat, no doubt. He knew he was busted. Finally, he bowed his head like a puppy done wrong.

"I know, it was a really ignorant thing to say."

My friend and I unabashedly agreed and dutifully made him feel, if only for a moment, as ignorant as he sounded. I had to. I could not let it pass.

He went on, trying to redeem himself: "But when you see two exotic looking women…"

This American just didn't know when to stop. Exotic? That's what you call an Asian elephant or a rare monkey, not a girl in a bar—because exotic, in essence, means different, alien, foreign. (Seriously, look it up.) That's why he didn't think we were American. Gotcha.

The night's episode got me thinking: How far have we really come when a blond man in a yuppie bar feels the need to casually ask a brown girl if she is American?

Just when you think everyone has the lyrics to Bob Marley's "One Love" embedded deep into their brains, you are sadly reminded that some neighbors suffer from chronic memory loss.

I have frequently claimed that I have never experienced racism. I'm beginning to think I've been naïve—or, as I would still prefer to interpret it, a bit idealistic. I now realize that prejudice doesn't have to be blatant.

I am reminded of another incident that occurred only a couple weeks earlier. While hailing a cab after a night out dancing, I decided to take off my four-inch heels on the open road. (Ladies, I know you feel my pain.) The coolness of the graveled ground was quite invigorating, actually.

Unavoidably, an inebriated Bostonian who wasn’t South Asian, took special interest. (Note to aforementioned American in bar: Yes, if you can believe it, ethnic South Asians can be Bostonians, too!) He hollered, "Hey look, that girl doesn't have her shoes on! That's because she's Indian! She's NOT American!"

Needless to say, I spewed some profanity at him. (I had had a few myself.) Interestingly, my half-Korean, half-Indian companion was still wearing her shoes. It must have been her Korean half that compelled her to keep them on.

So, in both instances, could it have just been the alcohol unintentionally triggering the ignorance of my fellow city-dwellers? Sadly, I admit that might be my persistent idealism talking.

If you are anything like me, you're South Asian but grew up in America. You've been walking the streets of every city you've been to, thinking that nobody is looking at you as if you are any different. Frankly, you figure most people don't care whether you are American since you don’t really care whether they are. It is just not an issue. Moreover, when you go to South Asia—the place people here might think you are from—your relatives refer to you as American. What are we and where do we fit in?

In this rainbow-striped country, aren't our differences what bring us together? Hasn’t there been an evolution in the understanding of what an American is? What happened to that melting pot full of all those black, white, yellow, brown and purple people everyone always talks about? Or are we all so separated that we only see what we want to see?

Maybe my friend and I were just being too sensitive. Some might tell us to get over it. So the guy in the bar was a jerk. Do you have to go make an example of him? Does that mean all men in Boston bars are equally dim? (If you really want to know, that's another essay for another time.)

One could argue that bars play host to people from all walks of life. A mixture of society and ethnicities come together and connect. We may live in neighborhoods with people of similar economic, social and even ethnic backgrounds, but when we venture out into the social scene of cocktails and conversation, we are forced to explore and ultimately learn. And the blond in the bar learned a thing or two from us. Yes, bars can even be educational.

Thank Bhagwan (God), for the power of one. If I let it go, this kind of ignorance would continue to breed itself. I can guarantee that the aforementioned American man in the bar will never ask that question again, sober or wasted. (He was more than coherent, by the way.) He might even repeat the embarrassing scenario to his close friends. And maybe, just maybe, they will think twice about what it is to be American, as well. Maybe instead of breeding ignorance by overlooking it, we can breed intelligence by discussing it.

There goes that idealism again.




Gitika Ahuja is TV news producer currently posted in Boston, MA. In her free time she enjoys frequenting Beantown pubs in hopes of stimulating cultural exchange with fellow Bostonians. She'd love to hear your tales from the tavern and can be reached at gitika@gmail.com.

The views expressed in this section are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ABCDlady.


Back to Top


About Us | Contact Us | Legal | ©2008 Asian Expressions