Home Free Subscription Get Involved Advertise with Us About Us Yellow Pages Team Previous Issue

Desi Making Waves

By Salil Maniktahla

S.R. Sidarth Speaks Out

On Friday, August 11, 2006, while campaigning near the Kentucky border, Virginia's incumbent Senator George Allen addressed S.R. Sidarth, a 20-year-old U.S. Senate campaign volunteer for Jim Webb, as "macaca." Unfortunately for Allen, Sidarth was filming this Allen campaign stop in Breaks, Virginia as a tracker for the opposing Webb campaign.

During his speech, Senator Allen said: "This fellow here over here with the yellow shirt, Macaca, or whatever his name is. He's with my opponent. He's following us around everywhere. And it's just great. We're going to places all over Virginia, and he's having it on film and it's great to have you here and you show it to your opponent because he's never been there and probably will never come. [...] Let's give a welcome to Macaca, here. Welcome to America and the real world of Virginia."


S.R. Sidarth

The resulting controversy over the meaning of the word "macaca" and various attempts to spin it into something that indicates its true meaning, or something that detracts from its meaning (depending on which political party is doing the spinning) threatened to derail Allen's senatorial campaign and could potentially be the deciding factor in the upcoming race in November.

ABCDlady had a chance to speak with S.R. Sidarth to present a little more information about the story, and his own thoughts about what happened.

Are you sick of the word "macaca" yet?
Yeah.

Did you know what “macaca” meant?
I did. I'd heard it when I was studying in Spain last fall. Not directed towards me, but I'd heard the term used.

Where did you grow up?
I grew up entirely in Fairfax County in NoVa [Northern Virginia]. I was born in Arlington, Virginia, but I was there a very short amount of time. My parents live in Tyson's Corner, in Dunn Loring. My parents were both born and raised in India. My dad came here in the late 1970's, he did a master's. They've been here for 25 years now.


How did you decide to support the Democratic party? Was there something that made you gravitate towards it?
Maybe nothing in particular; it's always shaped by what people around you think and how you're raised. Based on the values I was raised under, that would be my connection. Mostly social values. I believe pretty strongly in government non-interference.

 

"It was humiliating. If you've never had something like this happen to you, you don't know how it feels. "

How did you get involved with Jim Webb's campaign?
I was at home this summer from UVA [University of Virginia] and wanted to continue working in politics, as I have for the past three years. This was a race locally, and I hadn't worked on a race in Virginia, so that was something I wanted to do.

What other duties did you perform for Jim Webb's campaign?
I did whatever they wanted me to, really. Some of the major things I did…I was primarily involved with the field staff. So voter outreach...we also had a primary this summer, so targeting voters for that, and expanding our horizons and outlook to prepare for November.

Had you ever thought that you'd end up videotaping something on the campaign trail that would make you so notable?
No! I knew this was a practice that occurred, but I had never done it before that week. I had met Allen earlier on in the week. I had introduced myself to him. I started on Monday, and at his second campaign stop he didn't know who I was and asked my name, so I told him my name was Sidarth. He asked me what company I was with, and I told him I was following him around. He figured out that I'd been sent to tail him then.

Did he react in any way at that point?
No. He's a professional politician. He didn't really react.

Had you ever had any previous encounters with Allen? How did they go?
No, this was the first time.

Have you ever experienced overt racism before? If so, could you elaborate a bit?
Not to this extent. That's what made it even more bothersome.

How would you characterize your job that day?
It was mainly so that we had some idea about what he was talking about. It's good to know what issues the candidate was talking about, and where. Not to be obtrusive in any way. Just film what he's saying when he's making his stump speeches, that's all.

Did it feel like capturing his reaction on film was a goldmine? How did you feel after it happened?
It was humiliating. If you've never had something like this happen to you, you don't know how it feels. It's even worse when it's someone that society holds up to higher moral standards, like a politician.

Did anything like that happen at any other point during your trip?
Nothing of this sort occurred at any other point on the trip; everyone else I met was very friendly and nice to me.

Did you originate the videoclip of Senator Allen that made its rounds on the internet via YouTube and other online file-sharing services? How did it get out there?
I talked with my campaign about it, and I let them do with it as they saw fit. My stance is that people should see and hold accountable their elected officials for what they say. Something like this contributes to the transparency of the political process, which is a good thing.

Had you ever thought of going into politics? Has your recent experience had an effect on your attitude towards politics?
No, there's been no change towards politics. This is just a good illustration towards transparency in politics being a good thing. I think I want to go to law school, and then a couple of years down the road, we'll see from there.

Where else in politics do you think politics needs increased transparency?
Everywhere, really. I can't think why we shouldn't hold people accountable for what they say.

How have you seen the South Asian community responding to the incident? Have you felt supported by people (the South Asian community, people in general) in dealing with the aftermath of the incident?
Pretty much everyone who's talked to me has been very supportive. I also think it's good to see that college students know about this, and are becoming active in the political process.

South Asians tend to be an affluent constituency, despite being a minority constituency. Have you noticed South Asians of your generation become more politically active? Do you have a sense of where they fall politically? What about your parents' generation?
I don't really have a good feel on that, to be honest. But I do know that more people are paying attention now than before. I think those are only positive effects from this.

Senator Allen is the son of George Allen, legendary Redskins coach who led the Redskins to the Super Bowl in 1972/73 and once said, "Losing is like Death." Do you think there are people who vote for Allen simply because of his father? Are you a Redskins fan?
Mmm...I have no comment on that first part, and I'm not really a football fan.

Have you seen any of the t-shirts that allude to your run-in with Senator Allen. For example, the shirt with the frowning monkey and the text "Who YOU CALLING MACACA?" with proceeds going to Jim Webb's campaign? What do you think of these products?
No comment.

Have you had any difficulty adjusting back to school at UVA because of your newfound notoriety?
No, it's been fine. A little bit overwhelming still, to see people know about it, but not a problem.

Do you have a forecast for Webb's campaign for senate? What about George Allen's campaign for presidency?
I hope Mr. Webb wins.

What's next on the horizon for you?
Probably going to work in the interim. Where, I'm not sure.

Do you think that in the future there will be more of this sort of thing, people following their elected officials around with cameras to get increased transparency in the political process, and to report on things outside the mainstream media?
I think the real focus of this should be letting people know about the real person they're electing to office. I wouldn't know how to respond to that, but I think it would be a positive outcome of this if politicians are more careful about what they say, and more sensitive to issues of race.




Salil Maniktahla is a macaca who currently lives in downtown San Francisco. He spends much of his free time trying to convince the staff to change the name of the magazine to "ABCMLady," with little apparent success. You can reach him at salil.maniktahla@gmail.com.


Back to Top


About Us | Contact Us | Legal | ©2008 Asian Expressions