Home Free Subscription Get Involved Advertise with Us About Us Yellow Pages Team Previous Issue

Feature

By Uma Setty

Prenuptial Agreements: Love 'Em or Leave 'Em

Contrary to popular opinion, glamorous Hollywood couples like Catherine Zeta-Jones and Michael Douglas are not the only people today choosing to enter into prenuptial agreements or "prenups". Increasingly, more and more couples are considering prenups because they are looking to ensure that their assets are legally protected in the event of death or divorce. Some South Asian couples are even considering these agreements.

There are generally two opinions about prenuptial agreements. Some believe that prenups carry the assumption that a marriage might end in divorce. Those who subscribe to this school of thought believe that if a prenup is a necessary prerequisite to getting married, then marriage is not something you should be getting into.

Others don’t see prenups as unromantic after all and think that they are a realistic and practical choice for many couples. Some believe that if they enter into a marriage owning a home or another asset that they worked hard to obtain, they should be able to keep it if the relationship goes south. In this way, prenups make particular sense for couples who have amassed some wealth before marriage.

What is a Prenuptial Agreement?
A prenuptial agreement is a private contract that a couple enters into before marriage. Prenups are valid and enforceable in all 50 U.S. states. The purpose of entering into such an agreement is for the couple to protect their separate premarital assets and to provide specific terms that will govern the relationship as well as a possible future breakup. Essentially, the couple settles, in advance, financial matters as well as lifestyle matters.

For financial matters, state laws generally indicate that a spouse has the right to share ownership of property acquired during marriage. The spouse may have to share the debts incurred during the marriage and in the management and control of any marital or community property (property acquired during marriage), including the right to sell or give it away. Thus, if such state laws are not suitable, a couple may want to enter into a prenuptial agreement as a way of remaining in control of how property should be divided in the event of divorce or death.

However, prenups don’t only deal with financial or property matters. They can also include lifestyle issues. For example, some couples have been known to include clauses banning mother-in-law sleepovers, limiting a wife’s weight to 120 lbs or she must give up $100,000.00 of her separate property, requiring a husband to pay a fine for being rude to his wife’s parents, or allowing the husband to watch only one football game every Sunday! These lifestyle clauses are just as legal as the financial and property clauses mentioned above, as silly as they may seem.

Tips for Creating an Enforceable Prenup
After a couple enters into a prenuptial agreement, the big question is whether the prenup will be upheld in a court of law in the event of divorce. For the most part, the answer to this question is yes. However, bear in mind the following information that will help ensure that the prenup is enforceable.

First, start the negotiation process with your soon-to-be spouse well in advance of the wedding itself. It is unwise to present a prenuptial agreement on the eve of the wedding, when attention will be focused on issues like mandaps and henna instead of financial, property, and lifestyle matters and little time will be available to thoroughly consider the agreement.

Second, both halves of the couple might want to hire their own attorneys before deciding to sign the prenup. Since a prenup is a contract between two people, it would be a conflict for one attorney to represent both sides in such a matter. Each person should consult with their own attorney before entering into a prenup, as it is too emotional a time and too sensitive a subject for the couple to negotiate between themselves.

Third, you must both disclose a comprehensive list of assets and liabilities to one another in order for the prenuptial agreement to be enforceable. Each person should consider providing income tax returns and balance sheets early in the process. A court is not likely to enforce an agreement if there is not a full and accurate disclosure of assets and liabilities or if there is fraud or misrepresentation.

Perceptions of Prenups in the South Asian Community
Prenuptial agreements have become increasingly popular over the years with the influence of Hollywood couples. However, the idea of entering into a prenup is still a new concept among South Asian women. Some women really like the idea of being able to protect the assets and wealth they have amassed before entering into a marriage.

Sheila, a single, 38-year-old cardiologist, says she is open to the idea of entering into a prenuptial agreement if and when she gets married because she has many investments that she worked hard to obtain. Sheila says that, for her, entering into a prenup would be a “smart thing to do to protect the financial success [she] has been so lucky to experience over the past ten years.”

On the other side of the coin, Deepa, a single, 29-year-old pharmacist, is adamantly opposed to the entire idea of a prenup. She says that entering into such an agreement “implies distrust in the relationship before getting married.” Deepa adds, “Why would a person plan for a divorce before entering into a marriage? It’s just plain silly!” In this way, Sheila and Deepa’s views on prenups are not too different from how most women feel about them: they are either open or adamantly opposed to the idea.

The bottom line is that prenups are not for everyone. However, keep in mind that even broaching the subject of entering into a prenuptial agreement may provide a couple with a golden opportunity to discuss their finances as well as their beliefs about money and lifestyle choices before they get married. This might not be the most enjoyable topic of conversation, but these important discussions may clear up important issues that they will need to face as a married couple. Prenup or not, the more a couple becomes comfortable with discussing such issues, the quicker they will come to agreements about their viewpoints on money and finances.




Uma Setty is an Attorney practicing in Columbus, Ohio. She practices in the areas of family law, real estate and general civil litigation. She obtained her bachelor's degree from Brown University, a master's degree in public policy from the University of Chicago and her law degree from The Moritz College of Law at The Ohio State University. She may be reached via email at ups@mcnairpetroff.com.

Back to Top


About Us | Contact Us | Legal | ©2009 Asian Expressions